MOTHER EARTH MONDAY
Cruise Pollution
Edited by
Charmian
Cruise ships are floating cities that produce enormous volumes of completely unregulated or
inadequately regulated waste.
Today's largest ships can transport more than 5,000 passengers
and crew, and have the capacity to generate more than 11 million gallons of waste water every
day, as well as carry significant amounts of hazardous chemicals from onboard printing, photo
processing, and dry cleaning operations.
The cruise industry has a dismal environmental record. A report recently released by the US
General Accounting Office (GAO) found that, from 1993 to 1998 alone, cruise ships were involved
in 87 confirmed cases of illegal discharges of oil, garbage, and hazardous wastes into US
waters, and have paid more than $30 million in fines.
In reality, this number drastically
understates the magnitude of the problem, representing only a fraction of the actual illegal
dumping being carried out by the cruise industry.
In addition to the 87 confirmed cases, there
were an additional 17 cases that were referred to the countries where the cruise ships were
registered. Some of the 87 cases involved multiple incidents of illegal dumping that, according to
the Department of Justice, numbered in the hundreds over the six-year period.
Furthermore, this
figure represents only the number of detected cases; the aforementioned GAO report reveals
that the US Coast Guard's detection and enforcement capabilities are hamstrung by numerous
shortcomings.
Foreign-flagged cruise ships represent approximately 1.5% of all foreign-flagged ships entering
US ports; however, they are responsible for considerably more than this proportion (4%) of the
total confirmed illegal discharges committed by all types of foreign- flagged ships entering US
ports during this period, using the conservative estimate of 87 incidents perpetrated by cruise
ships.
The cruise industry's repeated violation of environmental laws is a matter of grave concern. In a
particularly disturbing case, Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd. admitted to routinely dumping waste
oil from several of its ships, and deliberately dumping hazardous chemicals from photo
processing labs, dry cleaning operations and print shops into several US harbors and coastal
areas, over a period of several years.
Ships were rigged with secret piping systems to bypass
pollution treatment equipment. Investigators said the company's violations were so unscrupulous
that they characterized the case as a "fleet-wide conspiracy" by Royal Caribbean to "use our
nation's waterways as its dumping ground," and so pervasive that the criminal conduct
amounted to a routine business practice. The company pled guilty to a total of 21 felony counts in
six US jurisdictions, and agreed to pay a record $18 million in criminal fines.
Cruise ships are point sources of enormous volumes of waste, which can have significant
impacts on water quality, the marine environment and public health.
The problems associated
with these wastes and their impacts will only escalate in the future, as the cruise industry has
been expanding at a steady rate of 8% per year and is projected to grow by more than 9% per
year from 1999-2003.
The industry's exploding growth, coupled with its legacy of
illegal dumping and other criminal conduct, clearly demonstrates the need for stricter monitoring
and regulation of the cruise industry's management and disposal of its ships' waste streams.
|